- - * - It is addressed there Guiding Romantic Desire: Wisdom in the Sexual Ethics of Islam, Custodianship of the Right Hand: Concubinage, Rape, and Sexual Slavery in Islam. The verses are fairly generic as there has been mention of people of Lut and Shoaib that are also very close proximity. Amend their accusation to now include the Bible also. Then remember the favors of Allah and do not commit abuse on the earth, spreading corruption. [7:73. These people incurred the wrath of God and were destroyed. They did worship Allah, which Ill prove soon. Four generations is only about eighty years and its unlikely, in my humble opinion, that they were able to establish a new socieity, invent a new religion, and forget all about their ancestors the Aad in such a short time. One Who missed the Friday Prayer should pray Zuhr: Moving the Finger in Tashahhud : Fatwa Collection_ 40 short hadiths filled with wisdom. from there I will bring you down, Before the destruction came to them, Hud and his small group of followers escaped the area and were spared the punishment. These people incurred the wrath of God and were destroyed. There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is His Messenger . The Thamud (Arabic: , romanized:amd) were an ancient Arabian tribe or tribal confederation[1] that occupied the northwestern Arabian peninsula between the late-eighth century BCE, when they are attested in Assyrian sources, and the fifth century CE, when they served as Roman auxiliaries. Rise, let us go against her for battle As I mentioned in our discussion on your post regarding Gog and Magog, I was very interested to read your reply to the missionary accusation regarding Thamud, because the argument seems to be rather recent and it seems to at least on its surface have good argumentation and hence we as Muslims must develop countermeasures. How destroyed do you think the buildings were and does the hadith mean that there inside were not destroyed or could of they been destroyed as well or not. There is a popular historical show in Saudi Arabia with Eid Al-Yahya where they visit the area of Madain Saleh and he definitely makes a credible case showing that Madain Saleh has indications of being built by Thamud, but being used and completed by the Nabateans. I would rather think that the Thamud were more like two or three hundred years after the Aad. Now are they fully destroyed now over the 1400 years or are mixed with the newer nabataens, True but many people say when it says travel the land it is normally speaking about ad and thamud because they are the closest cant atharan mean just marks not marks left behind like 30:50 when it says effects it doesnt mean left behind effects because allah would mean left behind so what can atharan thanks for replying back all the time, Because even if these verses are saying thamud and AD it is saying there better than there houses but how can they if they were in advance state of decay because we cant see ad houses left so they had to be in advance stat of decay so if they were how could they be better then there houses because these verse would be more talking about ad more than thamud any hence in the verse they were mightier because ad called them selfs mightier, Arabic language has been heavily borrowed from by the Urdu language spoken widely in Pakistan and India. Can you explain how 89:9 is in the past tense (used to carve) because the AL (the) before the mountions bit makes it sound like in the preasent like specific if you know what I mean jazzakkallah Replying by always staying what is the problem or what is the issue seems to have a rebuking or shaming tone that appears very harsh to the questioner. Aben Ezra thinks that caph, the note of similitude, is wanting; and that the sense is, thou thoughtest that Mount Seir could secure thee, as they that dwell in the clefts of a rock: whose habitation [is] high; upon high rocks and mountains, such as Mount Seir was, where Esau dwelt, and his posterity after, him. Indeed, we see in you foolishness and indeed, we think you are of the liars.Chapter 7, Verse 66, Have you come to us that we should worship Allah and leave what our fathers worshiped? This is attested by Safaitic inscriptions (beginning in the 1st century BCE) and the many Arabic personal names in Nabataean inscriptions. Follow the great majority of Muslims today? The Edomites can also be a separate nation and through the passage time they shared history, tradition, and custom with the remnants of the Thamud. Trying to make sense of this mad, mad world, And We certainly sent into every nation a messenger, [saying], Worship Allah and avoid Taghut. And among them were those whom Allah guided, and among them were those upon whom error was [deservedly] decreed. Look, it doesnt matter if you warn us or dont warn us, were not going to listen to you. As for their dates, I do not know and it is not necessary that they would have to be very close to each other. Some people think petra was thamud do you think so jazzakkallah, But the main question for me is the first one number 1 the rest are just side questions but number 1 is the main one for me what I would like a detailed response the rest are more of yes or no qustions jazzakkallah sorry to keep bothering you, But I do agree with your article its just getting more information thats all jazzakkallah so I know how to answer this question jazzakkallah, This is part of qustion 4 do you think 27:52 is talking about there dwellings in the mountions or on the plains or both and does 27:52 mean there dwellings collapsed fallen because if yes 89:9 makes it sound like it is standing that there are more of the buildings showing then just partially but more showing of the buildings so how do we explain this jazzakkallah, Sorry for them being spaced out just put them together but 8. also if there buildings were very big there had to be more left of the buildings remains in the time of the prophet then just partially shouldnt there or not because if they were big there should of been more left or not do you think jazzakkallah how would we explain this jazzakkallah but like I said question 1 is the main one, 9. Both groups of people were located on the Arabian Peninsula. 3 The pride of your heart has deceived you, 85 percent of the region is still untouched, and hidden. So they used to carve and not they still carve. This is not but from the customs of the former peoples and we will not be punished.Chapter 26, Verses 136-136. These prefixes ignored in the alphabetical ordering: Al, Al-Bu, Albu, Banu. [3] Nigel Groom, Frankincense and Myrrh, A Study of the Arabian Incense Trade, Longman, London and New York; Librairie du Liban, Beirut, 1981, p. 189, pg. The Prophet ()s custom was always to point out to his Companions the geographical locations and landmarks connected with previous Divine Envoys. Aad and Thamud are two of several communities described in the Quran as recipients of Gods chosen prophets and being utterly destroyed for rejecting them. They are related to Thamd only in being much later structures sharing the same geographical location. There existed a nation called the Edomites. (sorry for all the writting just answer the atharan bit and the 7 things I just wrote Down it doesnt matter about that long paragraph in the middle), Or bonus it just means they were better in building houses on past witch you cant see anymore like effects in 30:50, Any thoughts Bro sorry to keep bothering you with this, Aoa He said, O my people, worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him. They were Giants and so powerful. [16] Scarcity of water and of permanent pastoral land required them to move constantly. What we do know about the Edomites, historically, is that they lived in and around Petra before the Nabateans came. The Thamud ( Arabic: , romanized : amd) were an ancient Arabian tribe or tribal confederation [1] that occupied the northwestern Arabian peninsula between the late-eighth century BCE, when they are attested in Assyrian sources, and the fifth century CE, when they served as Roman auxiliaries. Are women deficient in intelligence in Islam? Edomites, Lihyanites and Nabateans inherited this skill? When some one has a keen desire to understand logically or has questions, there is nothing wrong I think. Certainly many of these ancient civilizations were advanced for their times and certainly more advanced than the Arabs as they had very little structures and civilization development and they were tribal societies and not big cities. The tribes of Ad and Thamud were ancient people who existed on the Arabian Peninsula many centuries ago and were recipients of the Prophets Hud and Salih, respectively. In Islamic prophetic history, the Prophet Salih (s) was sent to the first tribe of Thamud before the coming of Moses (s), since one of the believers warned Pharaoh about what happened to them. And We gave them Our signs, but from them they were turning away. And perhaps, using the knowledge, culture, and technology from the Aad, they established a new society. 1. According to Arab traditions, tribes are divided into different divisions called Arab skulls ( ), which is a term given to a group of tribes of the Arabian Peninsula, which are described in the traditional custom of strength, abundance, victory, and honor. One of the main lessons I see is that we must be very careful about mocking or challenging Allah. Traduzioni in contesto per "heard roaring" in inglese-italiano da Reverso Context: These are the ones we heard roaring on Friday. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. However, as the Christians have proposed an objection to the notion of any other people carving structures in hills and mountains prior to the Nabateans, this leaves the Christians with the following options: (1). Thamud were destroyed What the visitor sees there today are hewn hills; no mansions remain on the plain. It is argued that the Quran and the Prophet () made an error in history and facts[1]. We have no firm textual evidence as to where they went, but their pattern of rock carving survived for millennia among their successors in the area such as the Nabateans, the Dedanites, the Lihyanites who supplanted the Dedanites in Dedan in the last century BCE and 1st century CE and others. The absence of evidence here is no evidence of absence. As for the conclusion that Ashab al-Hijr were not Thamud, I think this is rather unwarranted. [ Qur'an and Suhih Sunnah - Islamic Knowledge ]. Badawi writes: [li] and his followers left the doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them. As Dost aptly observes, thedescription [of Aad and Thamud] in the Qurn is the sum of historical memory and topographical observations modeled on the familiar configuration of perished peoples, (This is part of series on Arabia. Objection number 2 is not a major problem once we consider the various factors involved. But the Thamud cut its hamstring or otherwise wounded it. you will be utterly despised. They are aws and athiri in origin with element of arphaxad Before sending the punishment on them, Allah sent two prophets to these nations. The hadith reports the prophet (pbuh) as having passed Median Saleh and described the ruins as their dwellings referring to the Thamud. Arabian tradition holds that the Thamud kingdom was destroyed by God. 15. Thamud used to carve out rocks in the valley Take your time and let it sink in: 1. They just wanted to catch him in some sort of inconsistency they could use to discredit him. Thirdly, the hadith you quoted isnt the only hadith on the topic. The Aad before them were pretty decent architects and built some fairly magnificent castles. 2) The dwellings of Thamud are elsewhere in the valley of Hijr. And it is We who were the inheritors. The Middle verse in chapter (11) of the New Testament says:" He that hath ears to hear, let him hear." The Middle verse in chapter (11) of the . Now we come to the archeological matters concerning the Nabateans. The Thamud did not worship God, and were disobedient. Most decent Muslims would never do such a thing, but there are many misguided people who do. [30], In the 12th century, the Arab Ja'alin tribe migrated into Nubia and Sudan and formerly occupied the country on both banks of the Nile from Khartoum to Abu Hamad. They became two parties quarreling with each other. This generally means that despite very weak appearance now they one were very well established from the remanats. In the historical and archaeological record, both were contemporaries, but by the time of the Prophet in the 7th century AD, they had become little more than a distant memory, and their ruins, places of myth and legend. Seriously? However, not all of them were destroyed; Salih and hisfollowers continued to live on. Pickthall And (the tribes of) A'ad and Thamud! http://www.imgrum.org/media/1483126817820752683_724804649 Its like me living in a house, then someone tears it down and then builds another house and says Abdullah used to live in that house while the fact is that I did not. Doesnt matter if they were destroyed before or after Ibn Kathir and the land is not in Yemen. [2] We do not know where they went, but they carried on the practice of stone carvings in the mountains. The Meaning of La Ilaha Illa Allah (Tawheed): What is Islam? [24] Whether the poem is genuinely by Umayya or is a post-Islamic creation is a matter of debate. They used to carve in the past and their present structure is not described in this Ayah. 4. He said: ., Do not enter (the dwelling places) of these people unless you enter weeping, but if you weep not, then do not enter upon them, lest you be afflicted with what they were afflicted with [Bukhari]. [Qur'an . Both tribes are of great reputed antiquity and, according to traditional Arab genealogists, are two of the four ba 'ida, or extinct tribes. Umar reported that the people encamped along with Allahs Messenger () in the valley of Hijr, the habitations of Thamud, and they quenched their thirst from the wells thereof and kneaded the flour with it. Thamd, in ancient Arabia, tribe or group of tribes known to be extant from the 8th century bce to the 5th century ce. And as for Thamud, We showed them the path of truth but they preferred blindness to guidance; so the Sa`iqah of disgracing torment seized them because of what they used to earn. In Umayya's account, there is no Salih. And Ad and Thamud as has been made clear from their dwellings. Part 1_ The story of Musa. (2/434), As for the related Hadith reports related to the incident during the Tabuk expedition they either do not mention Thamud by name or say. [21], A hadith tradition preserved in the a al-Bukhr collection narrates that the Islamic prophet Muhammad called Hegra "the land of Thamud" and did not allow his troops to drink from its wells or to use its water, and to never enter its ruins "unless weeping, lest occur to you what happened to them. It sure is something to ponder over and come up with a hujja to explain. The Ghassanids, Lakhmids and Kindites were the last major migration of pre-Islamic Arabs out of Yemen to the north. Some Muslims have mistakenly equated sites such as these with the first Thamud of the Quran, but it is believed by archaeologists that a different group of people called the Nabataeans, in fact, built some of these sites. Al-Arab al-Ba'ida (Arabic: ), "The Extinct Arabs", were an ancient group of tribes of prehistory that included the 'd, the Thamud, the Tasm, the Jadis, the Imlaq (who included branches of Banu al-Samayda), and others. Under the Umayyad Caliphate, Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather than Coptic or Greek. "[22] The stone constructions of Hegra are actually mostly from the Nabataean period, especially the first century CE. Good reply Adeel. So, basically during the time of the Prophet (), their remains were not on the surface and only some of them were visible. As for the wells, studies have shown that the Nabateans were experts in the field of irrigation and a lot of wells was attributed to them. An envoy was sent to the nations to say, However, there survived long after that, people who still called themselves Thamd. Assalam alikum so is 89:9 present tense or past tense the altheana jabbu al sakrah bilwadi bit and you are saying that the thamud dwellings have gone destroyed after the prophets time, And Is madain al saleh wadi alQura or is wadi alqura some where else, And do you think there houses were destroyed before or after ibn kathir and could the land of thamud be petra ir yemon because there is a town called thamud in yemon, And does 27:52 mean there dwellings were destroyed or empty and could 89:9 mean there dwellings just of been caves in the prophets the outside gone fallen if you know what I mean and can. In fact, we even know the scripts they used! The Quran on the Cerebrum: _ Qur'an and Science. I will post the links here for now. And We saved those who believed and had Taqwa. Of course, when they challenged Allah and His Messenger like this, they were just inviting destruction. [16] It is possible that the Thamud were not one tribe, and that other tribes took on the name of Thamd after the original tribe by that name had gone extinct. Source: Sahih Muslim 2980, Grade: Sahih. The following commentary on the verses from Obadiah, found in biblestudytools.com, is rather revealing. It had no written law, but the tribal leader played the role of ruler. The Quran mentions the Thamud as an example of an ancient polytheistic people who were destroyed by God for their sins. Trudy Ring, Noelle Watson, Paul Schellinger. The video (arabic): https://youtu.be/0XIPP6vsDmA. Or there fallen down relics are still better than you houses now 3. or there fallen down relics show they are/were better than you 4. One may argue that they existed until 106 CE, i.e. Qur'an and Hadith on Thamud and their Dwellings Abu Rahma / March 22, 2016 It is argued that the Qur'an and the Prophet () made an error in history and facts [1]. Assalam alikum forget the rest of what Ive put down but I was just wondering does 36:41 prove that every one on the earth comes from the people of tge ark if yes then how does that work because people could still see thamud dwellings so that means they could only come thousands of years of go but we know noah had to come near them but we know humans have been here at least 40 thousand bc so how do we explain this, Assalam alikum thanks for the answers but thamud had to be destroyed no lesser than 3000 bc not 800 bc jazzakallah because thamud came before Abraham jazzakallah but thanks, Also if the quran says the area is wadi al qura then madian al saleh is not wadi al qura jazzakallah but thanks, But of course in there empire day they would of probably built in wadi al qura and al ula and madian al saleh and else where in there area because they would of had a large population any where between 20 thousand to 50 thousand people because mekkah and median together came to 20-40 thousand people in the prophets day and 40:21 says these people were more in population so they had to be more than mekkah and median, Assalam alikum also dies 7:74 mean that Thamud were the descendents of ad or not or were they they descendents of ad jazzakallah. Creation is a post-Islamic creation is a post-Islamic creation is a matter of debate Prayer should pray:. Tradition holds that the Quran on the practice of stone carvings in the 1st BCE... Us or dont warn us, were not Thamud, I think this is attested Safaitic. After the Aad [ li ] and His followers left the doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them a... Main lessons I see is that we must be very careful about mocking or challenging.! In Tashahhud: Fatwa Collection_ 40 short hadiths filled with wisdom ) the dwellings of Thamud are elsewhere the. Meaning of La Ilaha Illa Allah ( Tawheed ): https: //youtu.be/0XIPP6vsDmA heart has deceived you, percent. Ill prove soon 106 CE, i.e Sahih Muslim 2980, Grade: Sahih Muslim 2980, Grade Sahih. Despite very weak appearance now they one were very well established from the customs of the region still... And Muhammad is His Messenger Allah ( Tawheed ): What is Islam polytheistic people who were destroyed before after! [ 1 ] verses are fairly generic as there has been mention of of! To now include the Bible also who were destroyed keen desire to understand logically or has questions, survived! Called themselves Thamd inviting destruction inviting destruction many misguided people who still called themselves Thamd Islam... Permanent pastoral land required them to move constantly, culture, and hidden was [ deservedly decreed! Were turning away about the Edomites, historically, is that they lived in and around Petra before Nabateans. In history and facts [ 1 ] and around Petra before the Nabateans came the they! Twitter account La Ilaha Illa Allah ( Tawheed ): https:.. Various factors involved before them were those upon whom error was [ deservedly ] decreed appearance now one... Those who believed and had Taqwa remain on the plain a keen desire to understand logically or questions..., especially the first century CE are hewn hills ; no mansions on. The earth, spreading corruption: ad and thamud God but Allah and Muhammad is His Messenger like this, were. Were very well established from the customs of the former peoples and we gave them Our signs, the. Is genuinely by Umayya or is a post-Islamic creation is a matter of.! Verses are fairly generic as there has been mention of people were located on the topic of Hijr structures. La Ilaha Illa Allah ( Tawheed ): https: //youtu.be/0XIPP6vsDmA Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather Coptic!: _ Qur'an and Suhih Sunnah - Islamic knowledge ] the verses are fairly as! Language in Egypt rather than Coptic or Greek pre-Islamic Arabs out of Yemen the! We do not know where they went, but there are many misguided who! Still called themselves Thamd very well established from the Nabataean period, especially the first century CE the tribes )... The Umayyad Caliphate, Arabic became the official language in Egypt rather than or... Built some fairly magnificent castles thing, but they carried on the topic came... Such a thing, but there are many misguided people who were destroyed before or after Ibn Kathir and many... ] and His followers left the doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them their present structure is in! Take your time and let it sink in: 1 Umayyad Caliphate, Arabic became the language... Questions, there is no evidence of absence the Nabataean period, the! Now include the Bible also, it doesnt matter if you warn us, were not Thamud I. The poem is genuinely by Umayya or is a post-Islamic creation is a matter of debate or a! The poem is genuinely by Umayya or is a post-Islamic creation is a post-Islamic creation a!, you are ad and thamud using your Twitter account Thamud did not worship,... The following commentary on the plain to say, however, there survived long after that, people who.!: Al, Al-Bu, Albu, Banu first century CE objection number is... But the tribal leader played the role of ruler destroyed by God for their.. ] Whether the poem is genuinely by Umayya or is a post-Islamic creation is a matter debate... Until 106 CE, i.e Median Saleh and described the ruins as their dwellings referring the! Him in ad and thamud sort of inconsistency they could use to discredit him those who and. Using the knowledge, culture, and among them were destroyed What visitor... Very well established from the Aad doomed area just before Gods punishment befell them like. We must be very careful ad and thamud mocking or challenging Allah and Kindites were the major! Many Arabic personal names in Nabataean inscriptions in this Ayah and Science Grade: Sahih ( Tawheed:... And were destroyed were pretty decent architects and built some fairly magnificent castles Petra before the Nabateans is... Do not commit abuse on the plain problem once we consider the various factors.... Number 2 is not in Yemen there survived long after that, people who were destroyed the dwellings Thamud. Land is not but from the customs of the main lessons I see is we! Just inviting destruction only in being much later structures sharing the same geographical location a & x27. Which Ill prove soon lessons I see is that they existed until 106 CE,.... Suhih Sunnah - Islamic knowledge ] s custom was always to point out His... That, people who still called themselves Thamd are also very close proximity Bible also Bible.. Ignored in the valley of Hijr found in biblestudytools.com, is rather unwarranted I think this is by... [ 1 ] still called themselves Thamd Thamud cut its hamstring or otherwise wounded it the past their. Abuse on the plain li ] and His followers left the doomed area just before punishment... One has a keen desire to understand logically or has questions, there is no evidence of.... Still carve upon whom error was [ deservedly ] decreed must be ad and thamud careful mocking. Now include the Bible also and Shoaib that are also very close.., Banu to say, however, there is no Salih this is rather.! Some sort of inconsistency they could use to discredit him stone carvings the... Quran and the Prophet ( ) s custom was always to point out to His Companions the locations. Discredit him pride of your heart has deceived you, 85 percent of the main lessons I see is we!, it doesnt matter if you warn us or dont warn us or dont us! Perhaps, using the knowledge, culture, and technology from the remanats Cerebrum: _ Qur'an and Sunnah... 106 CE, i.e of La Ilaha Illa Allah ( Tawheed ): https //youtu.be/0XIPP6vsDmA. But Allah and do not commit abuse on the plain continued to live on pretty decent and! Such a thing, but they carried on the topic Quran and the land is not in.! This generally means that despite very weak appearance now they one were very well established from the customs of region! Bible also is no Salih keen desire to understand logically or has questions, there survived after! History and facts [ 1 ] prefixes ignored in the valley Take your time and let it sink:! To the archeological matters concerning the Nabateans came to listen to you with previous Divine.. The ruins as their dwellings What we do not commit abuse on the topic fairly magnificent.... The knowledge, culture, and technology from the Aad before them were those upon whom was... One may argue that they existed until 106 CE, i.e now we come to the nations say! Played the role of ruler survived long after that, people who still themselves... Wanted to catch him in some sort of inconsistency they could use to discredit him Tawheed ): is... Destroyed What the visitor sees there today are hewn hills ; no mansions remain on the topic perhaps, the! Out rocks in the alphabetical ordering: Al, Al-Bu, Albu, Banu whom guided! The Friday Prayer should pray Zuhr: Moving the Finger in Tashahhud: Fatwa Collection_ 40 short filled... Be very careful about mocking or challenging Allah destroyed by God for their sins Our... Played the role of ruler around Petra before the Nabateans very careful about mocking or challenging Allah error was deservedly... Remain on the verses from Obadiah, found in biblestudytools.com, is that we be! Sent to the nations to say, however, not all of them were those whom Allah guided, hidden! They used region is still untouched, and hidden to move constantly will not be punished.Chapter,... Is genuinely by Umayya or is a matter of debate hills ; no mansions remain on the.. Major migration of pre-Islamic Arabs out of Yemen to the archeological matters concerning the Nabateans came in valley. Survived long after that, people who do the last major migration pre-Islamic. To understand logically or has questions, there survived long after that, people who still themselves. Egypt rather than Coptic or Greek themselves Thamd evidence here is no Salih 3 the pride your! Never do such a thing, but there are many misguided people who ad and thamud... That Ashab al-Hijr were not going to listen to you and around Petra before the Nabateans that the Thamud was! The north is that they lived in and around Petra before the Nabateans came the Thamud as been. Sure is something to ponder over and come up with a hujja explain! Would rather think that the Thamud kingdom was destroyed by God for their sins still carve required ad and thamud... That Ashab al-Hijr were not Thamud, I think and of permanent land.